No forfeit of faith for Jewish high school basketball team

By Scott Sandsberry
Yakima Herald-Republic
022510 Jewish school forfeits READY
GORDON KING/Yakima Herald-Republic
The NW Yeshiva girls' basketball team waits to enter the court to warm up for its game against Sunnyside Christian High School in the state class 1B basketball tournament in Yakima Feb. 24, 2010. NW Yeshiva is the first Jewish school in Washington history to qualify for a state basketball tournament.

Email_black_18  E-mail           Print_black_18  Print            Talk_black_18  Comments
Advertisement

YAKIMA, Wash. -- When it comes to balancing the tenets of religious faith with a schedule of athletic events, it's not much of a balancing act at all.

Faith comes first.

That is the lesson the players on the girls team at Northwest Yeshiva, an Orthodox Jewish high school of roughly 60 students on Mercer Island, will both learn and teach today when they forfeit a Class 1B tournament game rather than break a Jewish fast.

Already the first Jewish school in Washington history to qualify for a state basketball tournament, Northwest Yeshiva will also become the first school in the state to forfeit out of a state-tournament game.

The team is scheduled to face St. John-Endicott at 12:30 p.m. in a consolation-bracket game. Today, though, happens to be the "Fast of Esther," one of five fasts on the Jewish calendar that call for no eating or drinking -- even water -- until nightfall.

Playing the game without being able to rehydrate would be "an unacceptable risk" for the players, said Rabbi Bernie Fox, head of the school. Short of being able to move the game time -- an accommodation the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association wasn't willing to make -- Northwest Yeshiva school leaders opted to forfeit today's game.

And the players support the decision.

"It's really cool to be here, first of all. We worked really hard to get here, to qualify for state," said sophomore Julia Owen, one of the team's top players. "But we're also very happy to be able to show that our religion is very important to us. Although it's hard because it would be great to get the chance to continue, we're not wishing we could ignore the fast and play, because observing the fast is important."

Northwest Yeshiva school leaders had appealed to the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association board to adjust the tournament schedule so the team could avoid playing during the fast. The school indicated it would be willing to play at a non-SunDome site, even on the home court of its Eastern Washington opponent, if that would resolve the issue.

WIAA bylaws allow for tournament schedule adjustments for teams that recognize the Saturday Sabbath. But making game-time changes in this case, WIAA executive director Mike Colbrese said, would be unfair for the other teams whose schedule would be affected.

It would force championship-bracket teams to play early games on less rest, for example, and possibly without the morning shoot-around practice typically held at available high school or middle school gyms by teams playing in the evening bracket.

"As to the request that could we do some rescheduling to deal with this particular issue," Colbrese said, "that would negatively impact the schedule for all 31 of the other teams involved.

"And if we were to go off-site with (any rescheduling), we've basically taken both teams out of their schedule and they end up playing their game at night, not in the afternoon. And they're also not getting that state tournament experience, which is really what the whole thing is about."

Rabbi Fox said he understood the WIAA's position, but that it was also unacceptable for the Northwest Yeshiva players to break the fast in order to play. The team -- known as the 613s, a reference to the number of commandments they serve -- knew coming into this week's tournament they might have to forfeit their second-round game.

A victory on Wednesday would have put them into a 7:30 p.m. game today, after the fast had ended. But their first-round opponent was heavily favored Sunnyside Christian, one of the tournament favorites, and Northwest Yeshiva lost 62-25.

"What we hope to accomplish when we educate our children," Fox said, "is that the ethical and moral essence we teach them -- whether they be of a secular, humanistic morality or a religious morality -- that they will extend those lessons beyond their home and school into their life and actions.

"If we're loyal to our values only in the confines of our school or our private home, then we've taken the whole meaning away from them."

The team intends to show up for its game against St. John-Endicott in uniform, shake hands with the opposing players "and congratulate them and wish them the best," Fox said.

Colbrese said he didn't know if the WIAA board would consider imposing any sanctions against Northwest Yeshiva for forfeiting. "We haven't had that discussion yet," he said, adding that the WIAA wouldn't take issue with Northwest Yeshiva's desire to show up in uniform, shake hands and step aside.

"That's a teachable moment," he said. "Both sides have a lot to learn from something like that."

Ironically, were Northwest Yeshiva in any other classification or the tournament held in any other week, the issue wouldn't come up. The next fasting date on the Jewish calendar isn't until late June.

This certainly isn't the first time, even in the Yakima Valley, that sports has taken a back seat to religious beliefs.

The most prominent recent example was at Mabton, where star basketball player Trishi Williams -- co-player of the year and leading scorer of the South Central Athletic Conference West as a senior in 2008-09, couldn't play Friday night games because of her Seventh-day Adventist faith. The Adventist Sabbath is Saturday, with observance beginning at sundown Friday.

That season, the Vikings barely missed a state berth when they lost in overtime in their final game -- a loser-out, winner-to-state affair. It was on a Friday night, and Williams, the league's top player, couldn't participate.

"It's kind of tough when you have the co-player of the league and she can't play," said Mabton athletic director Brock Ledgerwood. "But it kind of puts sports into perspective.

"That school (Northwest Yeshiva) and those families are trying to teach those kids things that go way beyond sports."

And, in the end, Northwest Yeshiva did get to state, and the girls did get to play. One-and-out will have to do.

"Even though we only got to play one game here," Julia Owen said with a smile, "it was a really fantastic experience for all of us."



Commentsicon2
Posted by huh at 02/25/10 07:03AM        Post ID#: #27011

I personally think it is a shame that in our enlightened society, the school system could not accomodate these girls. Would they have done the same for a Muslim team?

Report Violation
Posted by misunderstood at 02/25/10 08:24AM        Post ID#: #27023

i think its amazing that children can still stand by there religion. But it is sad that they can not play, because i would be really excited to see what they can do.

Report Violation
Posted by SandiB at 02/25/10 08:26AM        Post ID#: #27024

Great point Huh.

Report Violation
Posted by BacktoReality at 02/25/10 09:01AM        Post ID#: #27030

Very impressive of these girls. Putting things into prospective, one weekend of ball versus the rest of your lives. Lets see some adults stand up for their beliefs.

Report Violation
Posted by phantom at 02/25/10 09:27AM        Post ID#: #27034

I give these kids a lot of credit for sticking to their beliefs and accepting the consequences that come with it.Unfortunately I have seen many cases in the adult world where people have taken jobs that require them to work on the sabbath then sue to be exempt.Which then requires someone else to bear the burden.

Report Violation
Posted by huh at 02/25/10 10:23AM        Post ID#: #27037

Oh so true Phantom. And the real kicker is that it could very easily been remedied.

Report Violation
Posted by MikeK at 02/25/10 12:07PM        Post ID#: #27047

I applaud the team decision but I really think they should have been accomodated. Is it really that difficult to shift things around to let them play? Come on.

Report Violation
Posted by huh at 02/25/10 01:53PM        Post ID#: #27059

Should we take the next guess and figure the athletic association will rule them ineligible for post season play? If that is the case all the Church affiliated schools should also be deemed not eligible for post season play.

Kind of silly isn't it. They should be applauded and the athletic association should be scorned. The solution is that they should have been accomodated and allowed to play until the were crowned the champs or properly eliminated by another team.

Report Violation
Posted by overfifty at 02/25/10 02:43PM        Post ID#: #27082

"What we hope to accomplish when we educate our children," Fox said, "is that the ethical and moral essence we teach them -- whether they be of a secular, humanistic morality or a religious morality -- that they will extend those lessons beyond their home and school into their life and actions".
_____________________

With that being said...shame on WIAA for not accomodating this team. Hows that for "putting kids first"? Keep up the good work Northwest Yeshiva, and praise to you all!

Report Violation
Posted by zdaves at 02/25/10 03:04PM        Post ID#: #27091

Congrats to the girls for a great season. It's too bad that the WIAA doesn't make a better effort. I don't see high school games (expecially the state tournament) being played on Sundays

Report Violation
Posted by topp1993 at 02/25/10 04:26PM        Post ID#: #27113

some religions only allow dresses to be worn by females. should the WIAA accomodate for that too? Come on God is a loving God, the girls could fast another day in show of faith?

Report Violation
Posted by francesgumm at 02/25/10 05:43PM        Post ID#: #27122

I am proud of these ladies for following their beliefs.
My hat it off to all of you.
you are real winners.

to the state organizers, you should be ashamed of yourselves. You could not have played ay YVCC or Ike? there is no excuse. NONE!!!

Report Violation
Posted by Read2Learn at 02/25/10 08:12PM        Post ID#: #27126

WIAA should be ashamed of themselves. Has that organization become so large that they no longer care about such issues?

Report Violation
Posted by dramamama at 02/26/10 11:58AM        Post ID#: #27222

I was mortified when I heard that the WIAA refused to accomodate these wonderful young women. Congratulations to Northwest Yeshiva for handling the incident with such grace and sportsmanship. And Topp1993, you can play basketball in a dress - what's wrong with you, and can you go back on your medication for it?
The WIAA should be held to account for this incident, the game could have easily been rescheduled, and I imagine that if you asked any of the other teams in the tournament you would have found a lot more gracious and sportsman-like young people willing to shift their schedules to help.
And the children shall lead us........

Report Violation
Posted by BuckarooCoyote at 02/26/10 01:35PM        Post ID#: #27233

Too funny...as someone who was the token gentile being raised in So.Florida, all I could think of was how bored and what a lack of news there must have been today. In Miami Beach this isnt considered news. Its just the way it is! I guess the folks of Yakima need to open their minds a tad, and realize not everyone is of Christian faith..Maybe if you studied a little you'd find this isnt really a news flash...Thanks for the chuckle..and girls..Great Job! Shalom...

Report Violation
Log in or Register to leave a comment.

Posting Guidelines - Updated Aug. 21 2009
Readers are encouraged to use these forums to discuss issues affecting the Yakima Valley. Debate the ideas presented in stories and other comments, but refrain from personal attacks and offensive remarks aimed at others; e.g., you may call an idea idiotic, but don't say the person is an idiot. The Herald-Republic reserves the right to remove any comment for any reason. Examples include material that is obscene, encourages illegal activity or stereotypes based on race, gender, sexual orientation, religious beliefs and other factors. Continued violation of these guidelines can lead to suspension or revocation of your ability to post comments. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, you can bring it to our attention by clicking the "report violation" link by each comment. Guidelines revised Aug. 21, 2009.

Registered User?