From the Yakima Herald-Republic Online News.


Posted on Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Nile Valley in a state of upheaval
Residents assess damage to homes; officials gauge prospect of future floods and restoring SR-410 travel
By MELISSA S
Yakima Herald-Republic

 

NACHES, Wash. -- A day after being hit by a massive landslide, residents recalled a slow-motion mass of grinding rock and dirt.

"Like a glacier -- rumbling and inching forward. A popping, grumbling sound," Ron Simmons said of the slide that lifted his house several feet and cracked his daughter's home next door.

On Monday, Simmons and his daughter, Rebecca, were cleaning out their homes and packing their belongings into the back of a pickup.

"This area has always been a little unstable but nothing like this," said Simmons, who grew up here -- about 10 miles west of Naches and just west of the Woodshed Restaurant -- and recalls another slide in 1956.

A similar refrain was echoed a quarter-mile or so to the west, on the other side of the landslide.

It was just a matter of time before something happened along that mountainside, said resident Frank Koch.

"We've been listening to it for about two weeks -- cracks and little rocks sliding," he said. "It didn't just happen overnight."

Sunday's landslide, more than a quarter-mile wide and up to 40 feet thick, buried a swath of State Route 410 and covered the Naches River, sending a new channel of water into about 25 homes. It pushed up the original riverbed about 40 feet in places, leaving rainbow trout dying on the high rocks.

The slide destroyed two homes and damaged at least three others, including two owned by two generations of the Simmons family.

Damage to roads, homes and property could range up to $20 million, said Jim Hall, director of Yakima Valley Office of Emergency Management.

The area was deemed stable on Monday, but officials warned that rain, the river's new route, and stress fractures in the adjacent sections of the hill could cause additional landslides in the future.

It may take several weeks -- even months -- to restore this section of SR-410. Officials also said the slide may have effectively closed travel over Chinook Pass for the season.

Work on a detour around the slide area is scheduled to begin today. The detour, which is intended only for local residents and emergency personnel, is expected to be completed by Friday.

It will take traffic around the slide on Nile Road, which roughly parallels SR-410 through the Nile Valley. As of Monday, however, parts of that road were still underwater.

The county plans a berm to protect Nile Road and stop the water from inundating the several homes along its south end.

While the state focuses on fixing the roadway, the county's "first and primary concern is to create a new channel," said Yakima County Commissioner Mike Leita, who toured the area for about four hours Monday morning.

"Half the river is going over the Nile Road," he said. "There is water running over and across the Nile Road, in some places three feet deep."

*******

On the section of Nile Road west of the slide, three men stood watching the Naches River's new path into a large red barn and across their family's pasture.

Nearby, the roof of a log cabin was nearly cracked in two.

Clad in rubber boots and stocking cap, Koch checked on livestock near the base of the slide.

"I've just been walking around, keeping an eye on everything," he said.

A few moments later he was joined by Lesley Schulte and Brain DuHaime.

Without enough gas to travel a Forest Service road over Bethel Ridge to U.S. Highway 12 and then to Yakima, the couple said the only place they could get supplies was nearby Whistlin' Jack Lodge.

They bought bottled water and chips the night before, when cash-only transactions were being conducted in the dark without power.

Power was restored to the area 1:45 p.m. Monday. About 900 homes were without power after the slide.

"We were lucky to have a little propane heater that we were able to snuggle around," said DuHaime.

He said the slide came as a shock.

"We didn't know what happened," he said. "We heard the rumble."

In other related developments:

* Naches Valley School District officials said the roadblock had affected 47 students and three staff members, although some parents are arranging to have their children stay with friends or relatives closer to Naches, said Superintendent Duane Lyons.

But some teachers on the other side of the landslide did make it to school Monday, he added.

"One paraprofessional drove six hours around through Seattle to get to work," Lyons said, adding that other teachers came down on four-wheelers via a Forest Service road over Bethel Ridge.

"What you're seeing is some expression of the rugged individualism of some of the folks who do live up there," Lyons said. "They have to be self-reliant."

* The loss of power and road closure hurt some businesses above the landslide.

Prior to the slide, it had been a full house at the Squaw Rock Resort. But by Monday afternoon, the place was empty, except for employee Kathy Smith.

"We're hanging in as best we can," said Smith, adding that the resort's store stayed busy during the outage. "We had to refund some money. It's going to hurt us a little bit."

* Access by emergency services to the affected area remains intact. An ambulance was stationed above the slide overnight. Also, the Nile-Cliffdell fire station is west of the landslide and available to serve residents cut off by the road closures, and a helicopter could be summoned for emergency medical evacuations.

For now, the Simmonses are staying at another house they own down the road. They say they're touched by the hospitality of friends and relatives.

In small communities like this one, generosity in times of need is natural, said Sherry Gillespie, a volunteer firefighter with the Cliffdell-Nile Fire Department.

"We're all one family here, this community," she said, tears welling in her eyes. "You live so long here, when disaster hits it affects us all. All of us will do whatever we can to help."

* Melissa Sánchez can be reached at 509-577-7675 or msanchez@yakimaherald.com.

* Phil Ferolito can be reached at 509-577-7749 or pferolito@yakimaherald.com.

 

Ron Simmons looks west along SR 410 at the massive landslide that lifted his home and his daughters' home the day before.  Simmons was allowed in to remove personal belongings from the two homes that were built in 1937 and 1949 by his father.  Even though the homes looked structurally sound, they were condemned.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Ron Simmons looks west along SR 410 at the massive landslide that lifted his home and his daughters' home the day before. Simmons was allowed in to remove personal belongings from the two homes that were built in 1937 and 1949 by his father. Even though the homes looked structurally sound, they were condemned.
Rebecca Simmons removes personal belongings from her new condemned home along SR 410 on Oct. 12, 2009 because of a massive landslide that took out the state route the day before west of Naches.  Simmons home along with her father's neighboring home was lifted at least 15 feet above where it originally was built back in 1937 by her grandfather.  The two homes were about a football field away from the primary disaster area and were surprisingly intact for being raised so high.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Rebecca Simmons removes personal belongings from her new condemned home along SR 410 on Oct. 12, 2009 because of a massive landslide that took out the state route the day before west of Naches. Simmons home along with her father's neighboring home was lifted at least 15 feet above where it originally was built back in 1937 by her grandfather. The two homes were about a football field away from the primary disaster area and were surprisingly intact for being raised so high.
Karen Callahan helps take personal items out from her friends' home on Oct. 12, 2009 after a massive landslide along SR 410 lifted the home more than 15 feet above its original resting place.  The home was built by the Simmons family in 1937 and looked structurally fine inside, however outside the driveway was buckled and dropped steeply toward the state route.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Karen Callahan helps take personal items out from her friends' home on Oct. 12, 2009 after a massive landslide along SR 410 lifted the home more than 15 feet above its original resting place. The home was built by the Simmons family in 1937 and looked structurally fine inside, however outside the driveway was buckled and dropped steeply toward the state route.
The day after a a landslide blocked State Route 410 and the Naches River water from the Naches River continues to flood over Nile Rd. and onto nearby farms on Monday, October 12, 2009.
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
The day after a a landslide blocked State Route 410 and the Naches River water from the Naches River continues to flood over Nile Rd. and onto nearby farms on Monday, October 12, 2009.
Before and after images of the Nile area landslide that Washington state DNR says covers SR 410 with at least 50 to 60 feet of debris.  The left image is a computer generated representation of how the hillside looked before the slide and the right image is a DNR photo showing the slide as of Oct. 11, 2009. (Source: Washington DNR and Yakima County GIS)
illustration by TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Before and after images of the Nile area landslide that Washington state DNR says covers SR 410 with at least 50 to 60 feet of debris. The left image is a computer generated representation of how the hillside looked before the slide and the right image is a DNR photo showing the slide as of Oct. 11, 2009. (Source: Washington DNR and Yakima County GIS)
Peggy Emhoff, left, and Juanita Wickstrom start making dinner for the Nile community and the rescue and emergency workers helping with the landslide on the west side of the landslide on State Route 410 in Naches, WA. They Nile Valley Community Church became a gathering point for those west of the landslide, and volunteers cooked spaghetti, garlic bread and dessert for workers as well the rest of the Nile community. (AP/SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic)
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
Peggy Emhoff, left, and Juanita Wickstrom start making dinner for the Nile community and the rescue and emergency workers helping with the landslide on the west side of the landslide on State Route 410 in Naches, WA. They Nile Valley Community Church became a gathering point for those west of the landslide, and volunteers cooked spaghetti, garlic bread and dessert for workers as well the rest of the Nile community. (AP/SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic)
Kathy Callahan looks out the kitchen window of her friends' now condemned home west of Naches on Monday, Oct. 12, 2009 along SR 410.  The home was raised at least 15 feet along with its garage (seen through window) and a separate neighboring home.  Callahan was helping the Simmons family take the most important possessions out of the home under escort because the two homes were in a treacherous area, about 100 yards from being completely demolished by the slide.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Kathy Callahan looks out the kitchen window of her friends' now condemned home west of Naches on Monday, Oct. 12, 2009 along SR 410. The home was raised at least 15 feet along with its garage (seen through window) and a separate neighboring home. Callahan was helping the Simmons family take the most important possessions out of the home under escort because the two homes were in a treacherous area, about 100 yards from being completely demolished by the slide.
Allen Roehl and Genia Auer live next to Rattlesnake Creek, which flows into the Naches River upstream of the landslide across State Route 410 that also blocked the river. The decided to not evacuate because their house stands pretty high above the level of the creek and also because they needed to stay and take care of their horses.
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
Allen Roehl and Genia Auer live next to Rattlesnake Creek, which flows into the Naches River upstream of the landslide across State Route 410 that also blocked the river. The decided to not evacuate because their house stands pretty high above the level of the creek and also because they needed to stay and take care of their horses.
David Leitch, West Valley Fire Chief left, and John Walkenhauer from Yakima County code enforcement go over each other's notes about the landslide zone west of Naches on Oct. 12, 2009. The landslide took out part of SR 410,  redirected the Naches River and forced the evacuation on several Nile Valley residents the day before.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
David Leitch, West Valley Fire Chief left, and John Walkenhauer from Yakima County code enforcement go over each other's notes about the landslide zone west of Naches on Oct. 12, 2009. The landslide took out part of SR 410, redirected the Naches River and forced the evacuation on several Nile Valley residents the day before.
The day after a a landslide blocked State Route 410 and the Naches River water from the Naches River continues to flood over Nile Rd. and onto nearby farms on Monday, October 12, 2009.
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
The day after a a landslide blocked State Route 410 and the Naches River water from the Naches River continues to flood over Nile Rd. and onto nearby farms on Monday, October 12, 2009.
Anastasia Rief takes a photo of Michael and Kim Jensen's home along Nile Road on Oct. 12, 2009 as the Naches River finds a new path around a massive landslide destroyed SR 410 the day before.  Rief came up from Pasco to assist her friends who recently moved to the Nile area from Tacoma in July.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Anastasia Rief takes a photo of Michael and Kim Jensen's home along Nile Road on Oct. 12, 2009 as the Naches River finds a new path around a massive landslide destroyed SR 410 the day before. Rief came up from Pasco to assist her friends who recently moved to the Nile area from Tacoma in July.
Frank Kock came to check on his neighbors, who live on Nile Rd. after a landslide on State Route 410 blocked the Naches River and sent water flooding onto their land. 
#mug
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
Frank Kock came to check on his neighbors, who live on Nile Rd. after a landslide on State Route 410 blocked the Naches River and sent water flooding onto their land.
Karen Callahan helps take personal items out from her friends' home on Oct. 12, 2009 after a massive landslide along SR 410 lifted the home more than 15 feet above its original resting place.  The home was built by the Simmons family in 1937 and looked structurally fine inside, however outside the driveway was buckled and dropped steeply toward the state route.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Karen Callahan helps take personal items out from her friends' home on Oct. 12, 2009 after a massive landslide along SR 410 lifted the home more than 15 feet above its original resting place. The home was built by the Simmons family in 1937 and looked structurally fine inside, however outside the driveway was buckled and dropped steeply toward the state route.
Slide area about 10 miles from Naches on Oct. 11, 2009.
TJ MULLINAX/Yakima Herald-Republic
Slide area about 10 miles from Naches on Oct. 11, 2009.
Brian DuHaime
#mug
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
Brian DuHaime
Lesley Schulte
#mug
SARA GETTYS/Yakima Herald-Republic
Lesley Schulte

Landslides are nothing new in Nile Valley
Resident talks about losing homes to landslide
Landslide photo gallery - Oct. 13
Archive Landslide photo gallery - Oct. 12
Archive Raw video of the landslide area
Archive -- Massive landslide shuts highway, clogs Naches River
WDOT flickr photo gallery
WDNR flickr photo gallery