Guest worker program

Is Yakama plan a way to assure legal work force -- or just a new tax?
By PHIL FEROLITO
Yakima Herald-Republic
Guest worker program
ANDY SAWYER/Yakima Herald-Republic
Wendell Hannigan stands in downtown Toppenish Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2008. Hannigan wants to charge businesses on the Yakama Nation -- including deeded areas in the city of Toppenish -- a fee of 50 cents per hour per worker for employing non-Yakama members.

Email_black_18  E-mail           Print_black_18  Print            Talk_black_18  Comments
Advertisement

 

TOPPENISH -- A guest worker program plans to fingerprint and photograph all nontribal workers on the Yakama reservation and collect 50 cents for every hour they work.

Schaptakay Labor Works LLC has been licensed by the tribe's governing body to develop and carry out a for-profit guest worker program on the 1.2 million-acre reservation.

The program, which its backers say is intended to create a stable, legal work force and reduce crime on the 1.2 million-acre reservation, would generate an estimated $12.6 million a year.

But it's unclear whether the proposal can be legally carried out or if it even has the full support of tribal leadership.

Yakama Tribal Council Chairman Ralph Sampson Jr. said the tribe merely licensed the business, not specific plans to implement the program.

"We're not endorsing them or anything else," he said.

But a co-founder of the company, Wendell Hannigan, says plans for carrying out the guest worker program have the support of several members of the 14-member Tribal Council.

"We're still working with them, meeting with them to create a strategy," he said. "I'm sure the Tribal Council and committees will support us once we get going."

Details of the company's plans were taken to at least two reservation businesses last week, but the proposal is so new few companies were willing to comment.

Business owners have until Dec. 1 to comply with its terms or workers could be ordered off the reservation, according to the company's business plans.

Mike Gempler of Washington Growers League, which represents farmers, said the estimated cost of $1,000 per year per full-time worker will drastically hinder businesses on the reservation.

About 12,600 people work within the boundaries of the Yakama reservation, according to state Department of Employment Security.

 

It's about tribal sovereignty

The heart of the issue, Hannigan says, is tribal sovereignty -- the Yakama Nation's right of self-governance as assured under the 1855 Treaty.

For more than a century, the Yakamas have watched non-Indians flock to their reservation in pursuit of land and employment. Federal laws allowed
non-Indians to acquire tribal lands.

Today, the reservation is a checkerboard of tribal and nontribal ownership.

Entire towns, such as Toppenish, Wapato and Harrah have sprouted since the 1855 treaty signing. More than 150,000 acres of apples, cherries, hops, asparagus and vineyards draw thousands of migrant workers to the reservation each year.

In recent years, gangs and marijuana-growing operations have plagued the reservation.

This summer alone, police uprooted more than $140 million worth of marijuana plants on the reservation, surpassing the value of the state's entire grape crop this year.

Also, as in other parts of the country, tensions have been growing over undocumented workers.

Closely monitoring non-Yakama workers would help the tribe combat those problems, Schaptakay co-owner Hal Kent said.

Both Kent and Hannigan are taking their plan beyond the fields and into reservation towns such as Toppenish and Wapato to have employers register all non-Yakama workers.

"It's a standard-of-living issue," Kent said. "Yeah, it's not up to snuff, and we've got to make it better and everyone has got to participate."

 

Tracking workers OK

The tribe could track and document workers on its reservation without any federal involvement so long as it's not bringing workers in from other countries, said federal Customs and Immigration Services spokeswoman Sharon Rummery in San Francisco.

"Indian tribes are sovereign nations," she said. "If they want to keep records of workers, they can do so."

But it's not clear if the tribe could require reservation businesses situated on nontribal land to register their workers.

U.S. Assistant Attorney Tom Rice in Spokane said he wouldn't comment on the matter unless the tribal government attempted such a move.

Hannigan said the tribe could require such business owners to register their workers because federal Indian laws give tribes some civil authority over non-Indians and nontribal lands on the reservation.

 

A tax issue?

Both Hannigan and Kent said their plan is to assure a legal and stable work force on the reservation while ridding it of much crime.

But Gempler with the Washington Growers League said that's hard to believe given the fee being charged to employers.

"When I was first approached by Schaptakay, I thought it was to help solve a labor problem and provide workers. But that doesn't appear to be what this is about at all," he said. "All of a sudden this has turned into a tax issue rather than a guest worker program."

Gempler also questioned what services employers would receive in return for the fee, adding that guest worker programs charging fees usually provide employers with workers.

"It does nothing to assist employers to bring in workers when there is a shortage of workers," he said. "And that's what a guest worker program does, at least under the accepted definition."

Hannigan said the revenue would go toward the cost of acquiring and maintaining the computer database and possibly put into a fund to help migrant workers return to their homes once work is done here.

"We may be able to work up some type of stipend," he said. "We're still not sure how that's going to work. We're still exploring those options."

Either way, businesses are benefiting on the reservation, and problems are intermingled with the labor force, Kent said.

"If you reap the most benefit from something, shouldn't you share in the burdens?" he said.

 

* Phil Ferolito can be reached at 577-7749 or pferolito@yakimaherald.com.

 



Commentsicon2
Posted by JumpMarine at 11/16/08 06:42AM        Post ID#: #869

This screams of being a SCAM! I wish that the herald had published the cover letter in it's entirety as it is full of complete garbage. These two morons, Hannigan and Kent, are in this specifically for the money. What was disturbing was the accusations that the only reason that there is crime on the Rez was because of hispanic ag workers and it was all non-Indian's fault. The fact is that Yakama tribal members are also involved with the same gangs, thefts and vandalism, yet the tribe chooses to turn their head when those members are caught. They state that you won't be charged if you use tribal members for the workforce. The tribe itself doesn't even use tribal members for it's ag labor force. Why, they have NEVER been able to maintain a stable field crew with tribal members. This is what it is, nothing but a money making scam. If the council decides to actually endorse this and push for it's implementation then I guess that they also should start enforcing all of the treaty to include the fact that any tribal member must gain permission from the US Army to leave the boundaries of the reservation. I don't see that happening anytime soon. It goes to show that the treaty of 1855 is worth about as much as TP since it isn't being used 100% anyway.

Report Violation
Posted by myYakima.com at 11/16/08 08:11PM        Post ID#: #871

I've bookmarked this on YakimaNews.Net:

http://yakimanews.net/Business/new-yakama-nation-guest-worker-program-is-taxing-businesses/

"These two morons, Hannigan and Kent, are in this specifically for the money."

That is the point of a business still, right?

"What was disturbing was the accusations that the only reason that there is crime on the Rez was because of hispanic ag workers and it was all non-Indian's fault."

I've been hearing for a while now how all this crime is due to illegal immigrants. Now, a business sprouts up to get tough on illegal immigrants, and now it's considered a scam.

"...any tribal member must gain permission from the US Army to leave the boundaries of the reservation."

lol where are they going to get the troops for that one?

Report Violation
Posted by Nick at 11/17/08 07:54AM        Post ID#: #874

I've been trying for 2 days to get this article to come up in my computer with no success. the site spurs an error on the page - it is still there, even tho today I got through enough to comment. As it develops, reading between the lines here. makes an fan of enforcement of immigration laws want to stand in favor at first sight. However, the way this plan is presented, it is a racist mockery of the concept of guest workers as we now know it. First, most of the remarks in the first comment above are correct. ADD: The Indians gave up farm work when new suckers for hard work for low pay could be found in the Mexican Braceros program. Now, after generations of welfare benefits and rewards to tribal members for NOT working, I doubt if a single farm crew could be found that consisted of all tribal members. I applaud efforts to identify citizens versus non-citizens, but to restrict all workers on tribal land to tribal members is going too far. They may as well shut down the rez. They can't even find more than a couple of tribal members to work hard enough to farm themselves, let alone do it for someone else. As to deeded lands owners - take warning, you moved into a foreign country with a foreign government - now you may suffer the consequences and have your land stolen back by that government for the good of the people. Sounds like Communism to me. it IS time to enforce the treaty - ALL of it. Make them print their own money, support themselves with their own taxes and have passports to visit off of Indian Country. We'll soon see how long their little scam holds when they are all broke completely.

Report Violation
Posted by myYakima.com at 11/17/08 01:50PM        Post ID#: #883

The Treaty is the only thing holding them back. They could sell everything with lower taxes beating all competition in the area. They wouldn't be hampered with the War on Drugs and have shops to sell drugs of all types. They could buy cheaper prescription drugs from other countries and sell it on the reservation.

It would almost be a complete tax haven for businesses to open up. A currency based on the gold-standard would give it a higher value than the US Dollar during its recession.

Report Violation
Posted by myYakima.com at 11/17/08 02:15PM        Post ID#: #884

I've had the same problem with the site. I would get redirected to voicesofthevalley.com, like they are trying integrate it without much success. I was able to actually log in for a short period, hence the reason for submitting the link to YakimaNews.Net.

Report Violation
Log in or Register to leave a comment.

Posting Guidelines - Updated Aug. 21 2009
Readers are encouraged to use these forums to discuss issues affecting the Yakima Valley. Debate the ideas presented in stories and other comments, but refrain from personal attacks and offensive remarks aimed at others; e.g., you may call an idea idiotic, but don't say the person is an idiot. The Herald-Republic reserves the right to remove any comment for any reason. Examples include material that is obscene, encourages illegal activity or stereotypes based on race, gender, sexual orientation, religious beliefs and other factors. Continued violation of these guidelines can lead to suspension or revocation of your ability to post comments. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, you can bring it to our attention by clicking the "report violation" link by each comment. Guidelines revised Aug. 21, 2009.

Registered User?